The Top Seven Reasons Rock is Dead (and How to Revive It)
There's no denying it -- times are tough for rock 'n' roll. Gone are the days of the huge multi-platinum rock records and the months-long stays atop the Billboard singles chart. While shrieking guitars and pummeling drums were once the de facto battlecry of youth and rebellion, they've now been relegated to a tax write-off for record labels. Just how did rock 'n' roll lose its way -- and more importantly -- how can it regain its former glory?
Source: Richard Cook/Stock Illustration Source/Getty Images
7. Stiff Competition
Source: Steven Biver/The Image Bank/Getty Images
Problem: This is an issue that not just rock 'n' roll, but the music industry as whole, is having trouble figuring out how to solve. In the simplest terms, there's just a lot more free sources of interactive and non-interactive entertainment available now than there was even a few years ago. LOLcats, Facebook, DVR, Xbox -- the bottom line is that it's harder than ever to get the kids off their asses and out to the shows to rock out.
Solution: Burn down all their houses. Or at least their couches. Either that, or the bands could make their shows cheap (or free). And perhaps even more importantly, people need incentive to get off their asses. And in the world of rock 'n' roll, that incentive is the promise of a show. Rock 'n' roll is supposed to be "spectacular" in that the event is a spectacle. That doesn't necessarily equate to microphones that shoot flames or Rob Halford from Judas Priet riding a Harley onto the stage in assless chaps, but bands need to give people a reason to come out to the shows, instead of just putting on the album and staying in their comfort zone.
6. The Fall of the Record Producer
Source: Nicky J. Sims/Redferns/Getty Images
Problem: The actual recording process of a record is every bit as important as the quality of the tracks themselves. But sadly, the majority of the records coming out now, especially in the larger sense of "rock 'n' roll" sound basically the same. Why? Because digital recording gives people way too many options. Digital recording means you have unlimited tracks to layer on top of one another, and unlimited freedom to manipulate those tracks however you want. In that process, records lose their unique personalities because record producers are no longer forced to find creative solutions to recording obstacles or ideas they might want to pursue during recording.
The end result is generic, unnatural-sounding albums that sound less like bands and more like products, in that the unique characteristics and perhaps serendipitous imperfections of human beings performing live music are so smoothed out that all you're left with is a totally generic and predictable outcome.
An example: One of the reasons Joy Division sounds like Joy Division instead of every other post-punk band from that era is because producer Martin Hannett had their drummer, Stephen Morris, set up his drums on the rooftop of the recording studio, which ended up playing a major role in the distinctive sound of their records. Bands and record producers really don't try things like that anymore, because the assumption is that if they want a particular sound, it's probably just a few clicks away.
Solution: Sometimes, less is more. Bands need distinctive-sounding albums, and sometimes it isn't evident how to achieve that until you just experiment with things outside the typical standards and practices. And the lifeless process of clicking through filters on Pro Tools probably isn't going to get the job done.
5. We're Sorry, the Record Industry is Currently Freaking Out
Source: Sheer Photo/Stockbyte/Getty Images
Problem: The record industry signs a band because they hope to make money off the sales of their record. But everyone shares music freely now, so nobody is buying records anymore. As a result, the record industry is in a tailspin while it stumbles around trying to figure out a solution before CEOs have to give up their private jets.
Solution: Leave the record industry for dead. More often than not, the only thing bands get out of record deals with major labels is massive amounts of “advance” debt hanging over their heads.
In the Internet era, bands can record their own albums, release them on services like iTunes and Artist Direct, and set up touring networks with similar bands across the country. Perhaps the real reason the record industry is freaking out is because they're starting to realize how redundant they are now. Or maybe it's because people now buy music based on its actual quality because they can listen to it first.
4. Where's the Scene?
Source: Kerstin Rodgers/Redferns/Getty Images
Problem: Every time rock 'n' roll has gotten a foothold within a youth movement, there’s been a strong sense of community among the bands that represent that faction. Think of the acid rock movement in the '60s, the New York scene in the '70s, the hardcore punk scenes in Los Angeles and Washington D.C. in the '80s, and the Pacific Northwest scene in the late '80s and early '90s. These bands supported one another and gave the trend a sense of cohesion and momentum.
Now, it’s the exact opposite – many bands seem to think the right way to go about things is to separate themselves from the rest of their local scene and attempt to ride the coattails of bigger touring acts.
Solution: One band can only have so much impact. It benefits everyone if bands make an attempt to bring together similar acts and create a tangible scene that’s bigger than one band and one gig at a time. It is advantageous to all the bands involved if people start getting word that an entire region has got something interesting going on.